Two policies with the same deductible and the same reimbursement rate can pay different amounts on the same bill. The difference is the order.
Deductible first
The deductible comes off the bill, then the rate applies to what is left.
- $1,000 bill minus $250 deductible = $750
- 80% of $750 = $600 from the insurer, and $400 for the owner
Rate first
The rate applies to the whole bill, then the deductible comes off the insurer's share.
- 80% of $1,000 = $800
- $800 minus $250 deductible = $550 from the insurer, and $450 for the owner
Which insurers use which
From each insurer's published policy wording: PTZ brands (ASPCA, Spot and others), Embrace, PetPartners, Pumpkin, Rainwalk and MetLife take the deductible first, and so do Figo in Washington and Chewy CarePlus policies that Trupanion runs. Healthy Paws, Pets Best, Figo elsewhere, Trupanion, Fetch, Odie, Prudent Pet, adoro and Lemonade apply the rate first. Nationwide depends on the plan: Whole Pet and Modular take the deductible first, My Pet Protection Plus applies the rate first. When the order is not known (Kanguro, or a Nationwide plan that is not named), Faunium uses the rate-first order, which pays less, so the estimate errs low.
The coverage estimate calculator applies each insurer's order for you.
Questions
Why does the order matter so much?
With the deductible first, the owner pays the deductible plus their share of the rest. With the rate first, the whole deductible comes out of the insurer's share, so the insurer pays the deductible amount times the owner's share less.
Was this article helpful?